Score: 8

"Good Fighting"

submission: Clash

date: March 23, 2008

I enjoyed watching this animation mainly because you did a good job animating all the fighting. The only suggestion I have is to add some color other than just having the whole thing literally black and white. If you don't like that idea, how about actually having shades of gray?

Score: 8

"Fun"

submission: SHIFT

date: February 14, 2008

I had a splendid time playing this game. It's fun and extremely well done. The levels towards the end were somewhat easier than the previous levels, but that's probably the only downside. I just expected some big challenge, although there were some twists.

Score: 9

"Unique"

submission: [fishes]

date: February 9, 2008

Unique is probably the best word to describe this. I enjoyed watching this due to how it had some real meaning to it. We are like fish in the sea because there are so many of us on Earth, and we are all doing similar things.

Score: 6

"Drumfunk"

submission: Nub&Scribbler - Our Mistakes 1

date: August 7, 2008

I appreciate someone who actually does drumfunk on NG. I like hearing different versions of drum and bass. I was hoping for something other than a simple chopped Amen, but I think the piano and the guitar are very nice. It would lead more people to think this is a "drum and bass" song if you actually had a sub-bass or something.

Score: 5

"Not Exactly Drum and Bass"

submission: There's a Drum in my Bass!

date: July 13, 2008

This isn't exactly a drum and bass song. It's more of a techno type of thing. Drum and bass is usually at 160 to 180 BPM, and the bass is not like what you have at all. Try listening to more drum and bass and looking up tutorials on the Fruity Slicer (for drums) and 3x Osc (for bass) on YouTube.

When you learn enough about the Fruity Slicer, I will be more than happy to send you the drums loops I use.

Score: 4

"Needs Work"

submission: GL7 - Glitch

date: June 29, 2008

This needs some work. It definitely fits in the industrial section, but for an actual song, it's not that good. The glitching actually gets annoying. I would suggest adding drums to keep a steady beat while you change up the glitching and set it to different instruments. At least there is a guitar.